Screenshot Contests

[BE58D]

I know the other sites hold these contests as well, but I don't frequent them often.  Do you think Simviation should host such a contest? I think that Pete could easily get some of the site sponsors to donate prizes for the winner(s) (top 3 shots)... What do you think?

[Woodlouse2002]

Who needs prizes?

Just the honour of having the title "Best Screenshot" should be enough for most surely?

[BE58D]

That is very true, but of course there has to be some incentive because not everyone has the same outlook as you and I.

[pete]

Yes it's a good idea but  

1. you've put me right off by telling me other sites do this ...  ;D

2. who's gonna run it?  ::)


You'd be surprised how much work is involved for little actual gain.... Getting prizes would be no problem (I've ignored offers for years now of free gifts for promotion) but the main thing is :

What software do we use to display the shots?
How are they judged & by who?

The one screenshot contest we did have on the suggestion of MS drew in the small minded people from the FS world we don't normally (thank god) see round here - the types who take it all too seriously & bicker about this & that .... At least this time I could think of a filter to try to keep those people out - like being regular on these forums for instance ...  8)

Maybe we  could run it on this forum - One shot. Anyone caught voting twice banned, only 50 entries ...  winner gets a weekend trip to Fort McMurray, Alberta  .....  ;D

Seriously though - it's a good idea .....

[BFMF]

And Ramsa would win every time!

[visitor]

This would be a contest to see
who had the best equipment,
My screen shots suck, I most
lilely have the worst computor
on the forum, and because of
personal problems I'm stuck
with it, but glad I have something!!
I would enjoy seeing the shots and
would be interested in judging, as I
have worked in photography for
many year and don't have any friends
on the forums, so I would be fair!!

X


   

[Woodlouse2002]

Ramsa wouldn't nessacerily win every time. I think that a screenshot should be judged on the content and not the quality. While ramsa's shots are certainly good quality they lack imagination with the content. So every one has a chance.

[Fly2e]

I think it is a great idea but there are many problems with this like Pete said.

I posted the thread "Are you a regular at the Gallery" to see who was really attending these graphic forums. I see alot of regulars and some who just pop in and I was wondering how much the Graphic end of FS2K2 appeals to everybody.
The quality of work in these forums ranges from, let's say "minimal" to "almost photographic".
Some of us are pros, some just like the "pictures" and others are just learning to "master" their talents.

Like Andrew said,
[quote]Posted by: Andrew N.P. Esselbach Posted on: Today at 1:34am
And Ramsa would win every time!

[BE58D]

It was an idea.

[visitor]

[quote]
quote:Posted by: visitor;AKA:X Posted on: Today at 1:46am

[Scorpiоn]

Ramsa wouldn't nessacerily win every time. I think that a screenshot should be judged on the content and not the quality. While ramsa's shots are certainly good quality they lack imagination with the content. So every one has a chance.

Thank you!

[Craig.]

why not make this a part of the possible pay option Pete? from what i have seen there are pleanty of takers for that option so you could make a new section where only those who pay can get in, that way you keep out those who arnt serious about it.

[BMan1113VR]

And Ramsa would win every time!

yah him, ansmara and joker would be the most common winners probably


btw i voted yes

[pete]

I had offered previously to do work for Simviation, but was denied... there were already moderators, and the one review I did do... was never published.

I'm sincerely sorry about this B58. You have been one of many people who have offered to help out & been (accidentally) ignored. I certainly still have that review somewhere - probably with a few more.

It all boils down to me being regularly overwhelmed with stuff to do - this & real life stuff. Things get forgotted & missed. An old friend from years ago wrote to me a week ago & you know - I still haven't even written back to him. I keep remembering then it skips my mind when I'm at my PC......

I would dearly like a partner in all this .... maybe I should get my act together & try to find one....

Sorry for going off topic here but I hate letting people down.

As for the screenshots - I think we should do it. I think the above ideas are right on course & we should run it from the forums - not from the main site.
It is inevitable that those with good machines stand a definite advantage - but that's no reason not to accept that & see it as another form of entertainment for all of us.

So now: We need to finalise a method & get a few people involved in administering & find a way to judge.
The last one had 100's of participants & that was far too much. I think we need to draw the line at say - 50 - one shot each & any cheaters will be severely humiliated in public  ;D

Let's do it ... & I think prizes are secondary..... (they are all just advertising anyways ... )

[Woodlouse2002]

As I said I think that quality should not be taken into consideration when judging. If quality is judged then it is unfair to those with less powerful computers and unimaginative imberseils with super computer will win every time. So when judging commences do it by content and the imagination used in the shot.