I've pretty much made up my mind on the Zune HD, I played with a 2G iPod Touch and looked at a bunch of apps on iTunes. I really dont care for apps anymore(which the Zune may have apps also). I just want it to play music and get on the internet, and the HD has a HD radio which is really nice.
I would say thats a bad choice but by what you said the zune is better for you. I love my touch just because I love apps. The zune's new month pack where you can get unlimted songs or whatever is awesome I must say. 8-)