Rip This Oldie

Here's something I took a while back. I'd really like some critcal analysis of the shot, so have no mercy..it lies before you naked and crying.. 
Have the "wings cut off look" that so many of us (myself not included) are critical of, been used effectively? Obvious that aliasing is a bit of an issue here...oversharpened I think..effective use of light, weather look realistic? Drama?


Have the "wings cut off look" that so many of us (myself not included) are critical of, been used effectively? Obvious that aliasing is a bit of an issue here...oversharpened I think..effective use of light, weather look realistic? Drama?
