Simviation Forums

hey all. im sure most of you know the aircraft in it but if there's anyone that doesn't, the P-51 is the lead, F-16 on the right wing, F-22 on the left wing, and an A-10 in the slot position.

any suggestions are appreciated!!



only a quick edit so i know its not the best.

Very nice!!

Couple of issues solely with the F-22

One; it isn't an F-22 It's actually a YF-22. The Alphasim F-22 is the one to go for if you want a decent Raptor.

Two; There's some compression issues round the twin-fins. Strange, considering it doesn't seem to be a problem with the other Aircraft.

However, those are minor niggles. This edit is really good!

haha yes you're right about it being a YF-22!!  ;D thanks spitfire much appreciated i'll see what i can do with the tail of the raptor!!  ;)

the prop on the p51 is way off....
and it just looks like 4 planes stuck on a picture with some glue

2/10

i know the prop is bad the actual one is just as bad that i have so idk how i can fix the prop, but like i sais this was only a quick edit and i didnt blend it very well.

This was taken moments befor the F16 and the YF22 collided into a ball of fire with the P50 cos it was too slow, and then A10 then joining in xD
just kidding, good idea here

John UK:

Go to work, have some beers and tell the chap some ways for improving things! Anyone can pick an image apart. The question is whether or not your have the skills and knowledge to tell the author how to improve it. From the one edit I've seen you post, it looks like you do. So, share what you know, M8!  ;)

Very nice, Chris! This is a HUGE improvement over the last one primarily because you used a nice, high quality background this time around. It just makes an enormous difference in the overall image! Way to go!  :)

Jaggies are easy to fix. That isn't going to be any challenge for you. It's amazing how many things you are doing RIGHT, especially with only 3 or 4 edits under your belt!  :o

To address what I subjectively see as the single biggest issue with this image please permit to make a few suggestions regarding composition:

1) As a GENERAL rule it usually doesn't work out well to have parts of the aircraft very near or touching the border of the image. Why? Well, it feels unnatural to the viewer and makes the image feel "cramped". It ruins the illusion of the plane being in the wide open spaces.

2) When assessing your own images it may be helpful to look at what's NOT there as well as what is there. What do I mean? Images can be viewed as essentially being composed of space and objects. However, the space is actually an object as well! Assess the shape of the "space"! If the shape of the space surrounding the objects and subjects looks good too, then you probably have a well-composed, well-balanced image.

For example, imagine the planes as being solid black with no detail. Now pay attention to the shape of the background. What do you see? Do you see the very narrow strip along the right side near the tail of the A-10? Doesn't that make the shape of the background look "out of balance"?  ;)

So, my subjective suggestion is to develop an awareness of the "space" as well as of the "things".

Keep up the good work! Slow and steady wins the race!  :)

Tallyho,
Don

thanks Don!! i see what you mean now that you said that and i looked at it again. it does indeed look cramped and i have to see what i can do with the background. if i cant fix it, like you said, (although i know it can be fixed i just shouldnt spend a lot of time on it) i will move on to the next one!!  ;D