Woah! Excellent. I like both, but #2 is as real as it gets.
One tip though, for the prop, I don't know what you did but there's a nice method I use to make props in composites.
Go in the airplane and set the angle (of view) to what it was like when you took the screenshot (or simply use the original screenshot you took). Cut the prop, place it in the middle of a new window (Photoshop, GIMP, whatever) and then apply radial blur. You'll love the result
