Newest composite...and others...

[FSGT Gabe]

Hey guys,

Here's my most recent composite...and some others.

[stuart1044]

I think....they are great...

In my opinion the third is superb, well done

[Canuck.]

where did you get that bellanca scout from?
ive been looking for an air cadets scout for ages!

[krigl]

I have to say they're not entirely to my taste, if you want an honest opinion.... you put more effort into cutting out #1 than you did on #4 - I love the background in 4 though, but not cloning the fighters and cutting them out more cleanly would have worked wonders... in both pics the aircraft looks somewhat flat. The other two look a bit over-the-top edited...not that I never over-edit  ::)  ;)

#3 would  be great if it were more subtle - perhaps you were going for an 'artistic' look?  And #1 would look much realer if the plane weren't so flat...

Sorry to be negative - you must have put quite a lot of effort in. You can dish the dirt on mine if you like, I'll be grateful for the attention!!

[FSGT Gabe]

Thanks for the replies guys 8-).

where did you get that bellanca scout from?
ive been looking for an air cadets scout for ages!

cadets.zip on flightsim.com .

I have to say they're not entirely to my taste, if you want an honest opinion.... you put more effort into cutting out #1 than you did on #4 - I love the background in 4 though, but not cloning the fighters and cutting them out more cleanly would have worked wonders... in both pics the aircraft looks somewhat flat. The other two look a bit over-the-top edited...not that I never over-edit    

#3 would  be great if it were more subtle - perhaps you were going for an 'artistic' look?  And #1 would look much realer if the plane weren't so flat...

Sorry to be negative - you must have put quite a lot of effort in. You can dish the dirt on mine if you like, I'll be grateful for the attention!!

No hard feelings Krigl...I appreciate it 8-).  We want constructive critism don't we .  Yes I worked harder on cutting out #1...#4 was really quick.  The fighters actually aren't cloned...it's two separate pictures...but it IS the same model...no repaints for that one .

And yes the other two ARE overedited...but yes I was going for the artistic look not the "real" look.

Anyway thanks for the pointers though .

- Kevin