Simviation Forums

.......

1854 Charge of the Light Brigade


In an event alternately described as one of the most heroic or disastrous episodes in British military history, Lord James Cardigan leads a charge of the Light Brigade cavalry against well-defended Russian artillery during the Crimean War. The British were winning the Battle of Balaclava when Cardigan received his order to attack the Russians. His cavalry gallantly charged down the valley and were decimated by the heavy Russian guns, suffering 40 percent casualties. It was later revealed that the order was the result of confusion and was not given intentionally. Lord Cardigan, who survived the battle, was hailed as a national hero in Britain.

Umm...listed in the section "incompetent commanders" in the book "The dumbest mistakes in military history". I think the author was right.

Hey! Just because you haven't won a war since one of those Franco Prussian jaunts! For the record, one of my ancestors was there, (Sgt.Mjr. Berryman)

[quote]Hey! Just because you haven't won a war since one of those Franco Prussian jaunts! For the record, one of my ancestors was there, (Sgt.Mjr. Berryman)

True, but everyone makes mistakes!
Anyway, he was a Lord, he's excused.


A.

True, but everyone makes mistakes!

And you've been quick to point them out, as suited, and make your own in the process. The biggest problem is that some people have to figure out how you mean something rather than only what you mean. Sometimes you often have a predetermined thought of something relative but don't explain that part of it out and we don't exactly relish having to read your mind.

Thats a very correct and true analysis....teachers always encourage me to 'be more clear' or show 'just exactly what I mean'... good work H.


A.

The Charge of the Light Brigade on a par of military excellence in the same way a Pot Noodle is haut cuisine

Were it not for the peom, would the Charge even be remembered as it is?

Felix is right.  Let's face it no one discusses the Charge of the Heavy Brigade which was one of the direct causes of the Light Brigade fiasco.

Basicly the heavies charged uphill against the Russians who out numbered them and won.  Not to be out done the Light Brigade were up for anything that would make them look good.  Bad move.

[quote]Hey! Just because you haven't won a war since one of those Franco Prussian jaunts! For the record, one of my ancestors was there, (Sgt.Mjr. Berryman)

Damn nice work Charlie! Even I didnt know that!

A.


P.S is the VC exclusive to the Army?

P.S is the VC exclusive to the Army?

No.  Other services have recipients as well.

Even I know that!

I'm just double checking!



A.

Tut tut Andrew not knowing that
Guy Gibson? Commander of 617 for the Dambusters raid?