Battle of Normandy won
Posted: Wed Aug 18, 2004 5:58 amToday is officially the day that the Battle of Normandy was won 
Sixty years on and all seems calm 
Sixty years on and all seems calm Now a year of Hitlers downfall... Ah, I love it. Simviation Forums
Flight Simulator and other chat
https://forums.simviation.com/phpBB3/
Battle of Normandy won
https://forums.simviation.com/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=35&t=100272
Page 1 of 1
Posted: Wed Aug 18, 2004 5:58 amRe: Battle of Normandy won
Posted: Wed Aug 18, 2004 12:57 pm11 1/2 weeks... Not bad. Now a year of Hitlers downfall... Ah, I love it.
Now a year of Hitlers downfall... Ah, I love it. Re: Battle of Normandy won
Posted: Sun Aug 22, 2004 1:29 amAnd if it wasn't for bloody 'Monty', it would have........................(I better shut up!!! 
)
Who was it that said it best?........Oh yeah - Ted Danson:
"That guy's over-rated" ;)
)Who was it that said it best?........Oh yeah - Ted Danson:
"That guy's over-rated" ;)
Re: Battle of Normandy won
Posted: Sun Aug 22, 2004 3:39 amA line that nearly ruined a very good film - pointless...
Charlie
Charlie
Re: Battle of Normandy won
Posted: Mon Aug 23, 2004 10:47 pmIt may have been pointless (I agree it was), but it was accurate. ;)
Re: Battle of Normandy won
Posted: Tue Aug 24, 2004 2:35 amTell that to the Eight Army!
Re: Battle of Normandy won
Posted: Wed Aug 25, 2004 1:50 pmI'll give Monty his props on kicking Rommell's a$$ all over North Africa; but once he got to Europe, he just kind of seemed to lose it a bit...
Re: Battle of Normandy won
Posted: Sat Aug 28, 2004 11:34 pmI must admit, I don't know a terrible lot as far as 'facts' are concerned, about Monty.
But it seems to me, after many, many years studying and rehashing and listening to all kinds of accounts and studies of the man and his WWII exploits, he was said to be 'overly cautious'.
I think this may well be a reference to his 'preference' for only attacking when he out-numbered the enemy convincingly.
I think the main criticism, at least as far as Europe is concerned is that he was too slow and cautious in taking Caen, which was the linchpin in the Normandy campaign and certainly contributed greatly to the 'extended' breakout.
But then, 'Market Garden', according to a recent History Channel Doco, was quite ill-conceived also.
I'm not sure whether it was actually Monty who disregarded or 'shrugged' off the Dutch Underground reports that there was a crack German Panzer Division or 2 in and around Arnhem, but the responsibility for such glaring errors and misjudgements must lie with the CO of any Op.
All said and done, he was obviously an outstanding man and soldier to have been revered in the way he has been.
But it seems to me, after many, many years studying and rehashing and listening to all kinds of accounts and studies of the man and his WWII exploits, he was said to be 'overly cautious'.
I think this may well be a reference to his 'preference' for only attacking when he out-numbered the enemy convincingly.
I think the main criticism, at least as far as Europe is concerned is that he was too slow and cautious in taking Caen, which was the linchpin in the Normandy campaign and certainly contributed greatly to the 'extended' breakout.
But then, 'Market Garden', according to a recent History Channel Doco, was quite ill-conceived also.
I'm not sure whether it was actually Monty who disregarded or 'shrugged' off the Dutch Underground reports that there was a crack German Panzer Division or 2 in and around Arnhem, but the responsibility for such glaring errors and misjudgements must lie with the CO of any Op.
All said and done, he was obviously an outstanding man and soldier to have been revered in the way he has been.