Simviation Forums

Are there any Sherlock Holmes fans here? My sister-in-law is an Christie fan (especially Miss Marple) but I'm a Conan-Doyle man.
Anyone else?

Me too, Poriot, Holmes; my favourite books. I managed to get the complete Sherlock Holmes stories for just

Whoa!! Shows you where my mind is!!  I thought you were going to say John!!  :D

Yes, I like Sherlock Holmes books and movies!!

Willit, yo' one nawty boy!



I've started re-reading James Bond again. Different character from the films entirely.

Oops, off topic: sorry!

Incidentally, there's a film coming out staring Robert Downey and Jude Law as Holmes and Watson, respectively.  Is this the reason you fired up the question?

I've seen the trailer, and have my doubts.  Downey as Holmes seems a bit too rugged to play the noble Holmes.  Law's performance (what we see of it in the trailer) seems to be neat enough, although he is not what I would imagine a good Watson to be.

Of course, I had my doubts about Trek, as well.

On the noveller side ( ) I do believe I have only read one Holmes: The Hound of the Baskerville's.  I was impressed with Doyle's writing, and looking at it, should make an effort to read a bit more.

I'd just been watching some on TV when I posted this, good old Jeremy Brett. I'm afraid anyone following in his shoes will face a challenge, I don't think Downey has what it takes, good actor though he is. He just isn't right for the role methinks...

Where's Basil when we need him ?