Guess Which One Is Computer Generated

[Anxyous]

Car's my choice as well, the sun looks oddly pink (I know it can IRL as well, but still...) and the beige buildings lack some detail...

[MWISimmer]

Which ever one is CGI they've done a fantastic job.

I can't tell, I'll go with the majority and say the car..

[expat]

I would think the dog.

Something doesn't look right with the depth of field. The specular effect on its nose looks hi-definition.

The dog picture is original, I took this one of my dog very quickly just with the macro setting................he was drooling all over the place as my oldest waved a biscuit close by so he would keep still If I played with the depth of field and lighting, then I could reproduce the picture with ease.
I am going with the car picture. The lighting is off and the walls are not straight. Saying that, with CGI I would not be surprised if the answer was the fire.

Matt

[BFMF]

The fire looks real. Me and a friend have messed around with photographing camp fires, and we were getting effects similar to that

[JBaymore]

The car?

[machineman9]

Car... For the reflections and the way the snow has fallen over it.

Just sticks out the most to me.

[Brando14100]

[quote]Yep, the fire looks real. The dog photo has a lot of detail in it, and looks real. And the moon photo could have been taken from a high powered telescope/camera.

The car photo looks fishy to me, so that's my vote...

[quote]My vote is the car.

[Ravang]

It is the car! Made by Marek Denko...


Here is another of his works...
http://www.simviation.com/yabbuploads/DenkoBuggy1_resize.jpg

[Anxyous]

Knew it!

Some stunning work though, I must say

[BFMF]

Thought so....

Some stunning work though, I must say

Indeed...! 8-)

[BAW0343]

Good job hes done there!

[Mictheslik]

very cool....kudos for the hard work and stuff, but does he know he could have saved a load of time by just taking a photo of a Fiat 500 and some artificial snow?  :-?

.mic

[JSpahn]

Wow Very good work....But the dirt and reflections on the car gave it away, barely, i wouldn't of guessed though if the title of this thread wasn't "guess which one is computer generated"

[a1]

Wow i would have never think it was the car. Amazing work there.

[BigTruck]

Definately some true talent there, but hey...we're smarter than that here at SimV    

Good post, had a good challenge to it.