This thread will almost certainly get locked; it is not a cut-and-dried issue, as can be seen by the variety of opinions expressed already. I'd like to explain my point in more detail, but not here! I'm not taking anybody's side here; please bear that in mind.
It's inflammatory stuff and decidedly political in nature... the point of squashing "politics and religion" threads is not to discourage free thought or discussion of important topics (feel free to PM each other endlessly on this or any topic) , but to keep these forums from turning into a shouting match or a useless cesspool of knee-jerk manifestos.
A prospective member perusing these forums should not be made to wonder if their participation should be based on their position on the death penalty for a given crime, or any crime.
THIS IS NOT A POLITICAL FORUM.
There are lots of political forums out there, and most are clique-dominated smugfests where Opinion A simply shouts down Opinion B; a waste of time IMHO.
Browsing these forums should be more useful and educational than watching TV... we need to uphold a higher standard.

In the end, that kind of posting really doesn't create more understanding or do a damn bit of good for anybody's cause- it just polarizes everybody.
You see it all the time on other boards, and we're seeing it develop here, yet again... because somebody (whose well-founded feelings are well-known here already) just had to slap a big red button.
I'm surprised all of you don't seem to get this... :-?