Page 1 of 1

wrong turn..

PostPosted: Tue Nov 08, 2011 7:19 am
by milesg
:) good morning, this is to inform that fs04 has a problem in the misaproach in maiquetia airport, venezuela. :-?.i made a bad approach in a concord(NIGHT FLIGHT) and the tower told me to go to xxx altitud and turn right...:.....:?????? result :'([glow=yellow,2,300].cash in the mountains that are south[/glow], ( i really did not crash because i now whats there and turnd left disobeying the tower,,( sorry for my writting ) although the map of missaproach is correct the orders are wrong... >:(
please be carefull in maiquetia airports missapproach ;D

Re: wrong turn..

PostPosted: Tue Nov 08, 2011 3:03 pm
by Strategic Retreat
It's not FS9 having a problem. It's the default ATC that is bonkers in its best day. Yet M$ regards it so highly that they copied it verbatim under FSX (and it's feared it'll be even under the yet to come Flight too) without even pretending to make an effort of issuing any real change to it. Only tweaked somewhat its look, full stop.  :P

In short, FS9 is good, as long you DON'T use the default ATC. Fly online, fly alone and without ATC using the charts, buy another and better ATC. But. Do. Not. Use. The. Default. ATC. And you'll be better for it. ;)

Re: wrong turn..

PostPosted: Tue Nov 08, 2011 5:55 pm
by DaveSims
The default ATC in FS does not take into account terrain or other aircraft when giving vectors. 

Re: wrong turn..

PostPosted: Thu Nov 10, 2011 4:42 pm
by Stewy44
Yes, whenever I fly into Innsbruck, Austria or Kabul, Afghanistan, I always cancel the flight plan when I get close and fly the IFR approach myself.

Those mountains make things hairy!

Re: wrong turn..

PostPosted: Fri Nov 11, 2011 6:28 am
by Strategic Retreat
Yes, whenever I fly into Innsbruck, Austria or Kabul, Afghanistan, I always cancel the flight plan when I get close and fly the IFR approach myself.

Those mountains make things hairy!


Almost ALL mountain approaches are at high risk, if you give those illiterates in the virtual control tower enough thrust to guide you to the general position of the runway. Though I must admit sometimes, like in the mountains of Japan, in the past, their competence to keep me from virtually remaining forever as a decoration on some mountain slope amazed me, there were all too many close calls to make it a comfortable flight, especially if you must do it in the night. Like I can never forget the one approach to Kathmandu at the yoke of a MD80, where their concept or bringing me to the runway was to make me do a final approach dive-bombing style (and I DO MEAN descending almost vertically). I really wouldn't like to let them vector me in some places like Sion in the Alps or Antananarivo.