With the popularity of LSA aircraft on the rise, why not a Remos G-3 or GX sport plane? They look great!
Of course, it would be wonderful if there were one made for FS9, or even FS 2002 (for the ones like me...LOL)!
There's a great series of videos from EAA about one of their employees who trained for his LSA license flying in a Remos G-3... they're very informative and quite entertaining to watch!
http://www.eaa.org/apps/blog/learntofly/